← Pentagon Plan for Greater Israel's List of Wars
The Unnamed General: Who Inside the Pentagon Had the List
Two questions come up every time the Clark clip is shared: who was the general who told him, and who "upstairs" wrote the list? Clark has never named the general, and this page does not guess. But a great deal is on the record about the officer's rank and position, about the generals above him who endorsed a regime-change paper that same fall, and about the civilians in the office the memo came from. This page lays it out.
What Clark has said about the officer
- His position: a general on the Joint Staff, the uniformed staff of the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Clark "went downstairs just to say hello to some of the people on the Joint Staff who used to work for me, and one of the generals called me in" (Democracy Now, March 2, 2007).
- His rank: in Clark's 2003 book, "a man with three stars who used to work for me" (quoted by the Washington Examiner, December 1, 2003). Three stars is a lieutenant general (Army, Air Force, Marines) or vice admiral (Navy). The book also calls him "one of the senior military staff officers," and the 2007 memoir "a senior general" (Salon, October 12, 2007).
- His history with Clark: he had worked for Clark before, which is why he confided in him twice.
- His later denial: "Sir, I didn't show you that memo! I didn't show it to you!" Clark agrees: he told him not to.
- His name: "I'm not going to give you his name." Clark has kept that promise in every telling for 23 years.
Clark's discretion protects a career officer who spoke to a former commander in confidence. It also means the only person who could confirm the paper's exact wording has never been asked under oath. No congressional committee has called Clark to testify in closed session, as Joe Conason urged in 2007.
The generals above him: they endorsed regime change that fall
The Joint Staff general was not acting alone. According to Douglas Feith's memoir, as reported by Gareth Porter, Rumsfeld's September 30, 2001 paper calling for "new regimes" was worked out with the top of the uniformed chain:
- Gen. Henry Shelton, the outgoing Chairman of the Joint Chiefs.
- Gen. Richard Myers, the incoming Chairman, who helped revise the draft. On the afternoon of 9/11, Rumsfeld's aide's notes record Rumsfeld instructing Myers and his staff to broaden the response beyond al-Qaeda.
- Gen. John Abizaid, then Director of the Joint Staff, the officer who runs the Joint Staff day to day. He "enthusiastically endorsed" the paper, wrote "This is an exceptionally important memo, which gives clear strategic vision," and recommended that Myers "support this approach."
Source: Gareth Porter, Inter Press Service, May 5, 2008. Porter's conclusion: the aim of overturning governments in Iraq, Iran, Syria and four other countries "was supported explicitly by the country's top military leaders."
That is the environment Clark's officer worked in. The head of the Joint Staff had just endorsed a paper from "upstairs" that called for new regimes. When one of his generals held up a paper "down from upstairs" and said "we can take down governments," he was describing the policy of his own chain of command. This page does not say that any of these men was Clark's officer; it says the paper Clark heard about fits exactly what the Joint Staff's leadership was endorsing.
The civilians "upstairs"
The memo came "from upstairs," the Secretary of Defense's office. Who was there in the fall of 2001:
- Donald Rumsfeld, Secretary of Defense.
- Paul Wolfowitz, Deputy Secretary of Defense, whom Clark saw on his first visit and who, Clark says, had sketched a similar plan to him in 1991.
- Douglas Feith, Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, whose book later quoted the September 30 paper with the country names blacked out.
- Stephen Cambone, the Rumsfeld aide whose handwritten notes recorded "Go massive" on 9/11.
- In Feith's policy office: William Luti and Abram Shulsky (the Office of Special Plans), David Wurmser (principal author of the 1996 A Clean Break for Netanyahu), Michael Maloof, Michael Rubin, and the Iran desk officer Lawrence Franklin, who later pleaded guilty to passing classified information on Iran policy to AIPAC officials (HNN, September 27, 2004; Middle East Policy, summer 2004 (PDF)).
- Chairing the Pentagon's Defense Policy Board: Richard Perle, head of the 1996 A Clean Break study group.
Scott Horton, on Joe Rogan's program, walked through much the same roster and concluded that the targets were "in many cases, Israel's list of enemies" (@ZachJones1994 on X, May 22, 2026; see Scott Horton). Clark himself named "Wolfowitz and Cheney and Rumsfeld" and "a half dozen other collaborators from the Project for a New American Century."
The other people who say they saw it
- Lawrence Wilkerson, Colin Powell's chief of staff: "I had a security clearance and I did see it and what he said is basically correct." He is a separate witness, from the State Department, not Clark's officer. See Lawrence Wilkerson.
- @ColonelTowner, an X account presenting itself as a retired colonel at Central Command in 2001: "The J2 was given a list of 5 countries as candidates on where to go after AFG almost immediately. Those same 5 countries were on Gen Wesley Clark's famous 7 countries in 5 yrs comment" (X, September 25, 2025). He says Clark "was given the names" within two weeks of 9/11, and that the other two countries fell under European Command.
- Karen Kwiatkowski, a retired Air Force lieutenant colonel who worked in the Pentagon's Near East policy office before the Iraq war, has described "the second set of rules for Israelis" in the building (Kla.TV North America on X, September 9, 2026). She has not said she saw the seven-country memo.
Nobody in any of the 96 research captures for this section identifies the Joint Staff general by name. This page leaves him unnamed.
Why it matters
The question "who wrote the list?" has an answer at the level of offices even without the officer's name: the Office of the Secretary of Defense, staffed at its policy core by the men who had written Israel's 1996 strategy paper, with the Director of the Joint Staff endorsing a regime-change paper from the same office that same fall. That is the bridge from Clark's "memo from upstairs" to Was the list Israel's goal? and Israel inside the Pentagon.
Status: The officer: Unknown. Donald Rumsfeld is deceased (2021). Paul Wolfowitz is alive. Douglas Feith is alive. John Abizaid is alive. Richard Perle is alive. David Wurmser is alive. Lawrence Wilkerson is alive. Karen Kwiatkowski is alive. Nothing on this page states that any living person committed a crime beyond what a court has established.
Sources
- Democracy Now, March 2, 2007
- Washington Examiner, December 1, 2003
- Joe Conason, Salon, October 12, 2007
- Gareth Porter, Inter Press Service, May 5, 2008
- HNN, September 27, 2004
- Middle East Policy, summer 2004 (PDF reprint)
- @ZachJones1994 on X, May 22, 2026
- @ColonelTowner on X, September 25, 2025
- Kla.TV North America on X, September 9, 2026
Research captures: twitter/t03__v025.md through t03__v036.md, t04__v037.md through t04__v048.md, t08__v087.md, t08__v095.md
Related Areas
Last Updated: 2026-09-26