Skip to main content

← Plato's Ethics on the Black Horse

Everyone Tells Parents to Open Their Eyes: What Each Side Is Pitching, and What the Record Shows

Since the United States began bombing Iran on February 28, 2026, American parents have been told to "open your eyes" by people on every side of this war. Supporters say it: open your eyes and see that this war keeps your children out of the next one. Opponents say it: open your eyes and see that your children are next. The Iranian government has said it to American parents too.

They cannot all be right. The way to decide is not to pick the voice that frightens or flatters you most. It is to ask of each pitch what it rests on, and open that document. When a parent does that with this war, the pattern is consistent. The pitches that told parents to relax have been contradicted by the calendar and by the law. The warnings about sons have been confirmed by the Selective Service plan, the White House's own words, and an Israeli newspaper.

Why Plato helps here​

In Plato's Phaedrus, the soul is a chariot with a driver and two horses. The black horse wants what is pleasant and easy. The white horse wants honor and to do right. The driver's job is to look before he pulls (The Phaedrus Passage).

A pitch aimed at a parent almost always speaks to one horse. Some speak to comfort: it will be over soon, your kids will never be involved. Some speak to honor and belonging: be on the winning side, finish the job. Some speak to fear. None of those is evidence. The driver's question is always the same: what is underneath it?

The pitches for the war, as made to parents​

  • "An investment in your children." The President's April 1, 2026 address, as transcribed by Owen Gregorian and credited to The Gateway Pundit: the 13 Americans killed by then "laid down their lives in this fight to prevent our children from ever having to face a nuclear Iran"; the war is "a true investment in your children and your grandchildren's future" (@OwenGregorian, April 2, 2026).
  • "Open your eyes and ears." A widely shared post aimed at older Americans said the war was fought "so YOUR children and grandchildren DO NOT have to fight and die in FOREVER WARS," and told readers to skip "numbers, long ass posts, complex analysis" and "Just use that thing between your ears" (@aj_inapi, September 20, 2026).
  • "Over in roughly three weeks." A summary of the historian Victor Davis Hanson, March 9: "this is not a forever war. No ground troops" (@MichaelARothman, March 9, 2026).
  • "The winning team." An open letter by the columnist Hillel Fuld told critics their parents and teachers had lied to them, and asked: "Do you want to be on the winning team or the losing team?" (@HilzFuld, March 4, 2026).
  • "Every bomb we drop is a win." A September post: "Iran: our objectives were to stop irans nukes and weaken its military. Every bomb we drop is a win. In no universe are we 'losing' ... Open your eyes!" (@frgtr46052602, September 24, 2026).
  • Iranian families abroad. Some Iranian-Americans support the war out of their own family losses. One wrote: "My parents are in Tehran ... I have lost my brother to this tyranny. AND YES, I fully support this war" (@urbaba, March 31, 2026). His grief is real, and the Iranian government's crimes against its own people are real. Neither answers the question an American parent must answer: why an American son should fight on Iranian soil in a war Israel's own ministers say they are happy to sit out (reading item 7).

Notice what these have in common. They speak to comfort (short war, no troops), to belonging (the winning team), and to trust (use your gut, see the direction). None hands the parent a document to check. The page Being Told Not to Look gathers more of them.

The warnings, as made to parents​

  • "Not my son, over my dead body." Former Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, a mother, March 9 (The Independent via Yahoo).
  • "Sons and daughters." A Marine veteran removed from a March 4 hearing: "America does not want to send its sons and daughters to war for Israel!" (ADL, March 2026).
  • "In service of greater Israel." Former Congressman Dennis Kucinich, on the first day: the United States had been "reduced to being an arm of the Israeli government, in service of greater Israel" (as posted by @RobbinMilne, March 1, 2026).
  • "The mountains of Iran." A September post described the choice as whether to "vote for your kids/brothers/dads to die in the mountains of Iran" (@SituationFasc, September 22, 2026).
  • "Your 5 children." "Are YOU willing to send YOUR 5 children over there to die? If you aren't, why would you expect some other mother or father to do so?" (@CynicalTrader82, September 24, 2026).
  • Parents' fear. "Panic is setting in. Parents and young people are terrified of a potential draft for Trump's war in Iran" (@FurkanGozukara, March 15, 2026).

These warnings point at documents a parent can open: the Selective Service plan, the White House transcript, the Jerusalem Post column, the Times of Israel.

The enemy government talks to American parents too​

Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesman, Esmaeil Baqaei, answered the Jerusalem Post column in September by addressing American families: "Why should your sons and daughters be offered debt forgiveness in exchange for fighting and dying in a war Israel wants continued & expanded?" and "Do not let anyone turn your children into mercenaries for their illegal 'war of choice'" (as rendered by TRT World, September 5, 2026). In March, the Indian outlet WION headlined an Iranian appeal: "Don't be 'misled by warmongers Trump and Netanyahu, don't send your children to hell'" (@WIONews, March 26, 2026).

A parent should read these as messages from a government at war, designed to move American opinion. But the test is the same as for every other pitch: what does it point to? Baqaei pointed to an Israeli newspaper. The column is real, and a parent can read it without him.

The test, applied​

You do not have to decide whom to trust. You only have to ask of each claim the two questions an investigative-reporting network teaches its journalists: "1. How do we know this is true?" and "2. What can I use to prove it?" (BIRD). Applied to the pitches above:

PitchWhat it rests onWhat the record shows
"Over in three weeks"; "no ground troops"A paraphrased briefingSeven months later, strikes continue and U.S. troops are dying (Predictions Versus the Calendar)
"Not part of the current plan right now"A White House answerThe same answer keeps "options on the table"; automatic registration is law for December 2026 (reading items 1 and 3)
"An investment in your children"A presidential addressAn Israeli paper counts 750,000 to 1.5 million American troops needed for a ground war (reading item 7)
"In service of greater Israel"A former congressman's readingIsrael's prime minister said "Very much" to Greater Israel; Clark's list ended with Iran (reading items 4 and 5)

The pitches that asked parents to relax rest on predictions and promises. The warnings rest on documents. That is the difference a parent needs.

Go deeper:

A method shared across sides​

Parents who disagree about this war can still share a method. Amani Zang, a mother who supports the war, teaches her daughter that when she hears a judgment, she should "ask for specific reasons to back that statement ... If they cannot provide it, you hold your own thought, and go do research on your own" (@amani_zang, August 20, 2026). Apply her rule to the war itself. Ask for the reasons your son would be sent to Iran. Ask for the document. If no one can provide it, hold your own thought.

What this means​

The black horse is not only the voice that says don't look. It is also the voice that says look here, and only here: at the comforting prediction, the winning team, the flattering promise. The way out is to ask every side the same two questions, and to believe the side that can answer them with documents.

Sources​

Research captures: twitter/t09__v108.md, t10__v109.md, t10__v113.md, t10__v118.md, t10__v120.md, t71__v847.md, t72__v862.md, t72__v864.md, t73__v865.md, t73__v869.md.

Status: Donald Trump, Victor Davis Hanson, M. A. Rothman, Hillel Fuld, Marjorie Taylor Greene, Brian McGinnis, Dennis Kucinich, Esmaeil Baqaei, and Amani Zang are alive. Nothing on this page is a claim that any of them committed a crime.

Last Updated: 2026-09-26

Last updated on