Skip to main content

← Standing Up Without Violence

Why Never Violence: Plato's Reins, the Law, and What Worked

A parent who learns that the machinery for a forced draft is being built, and that the war was started on a case the government's own intelligence did not support, will feel anger. That anger is Plato's white horse, spirit, and it is good when it serves reason. This page explains why it must stay on the reins.

Plato's answer​

In the Republic, spirit is the natural ally of reason "when not corrupted by bad education" (441a), and "he is to be deemed courageous whose spirit retains in pleasure and in pain the commands of reason about what he ought or ought not to fear" (442b–c, trans. Jowett, Gutenberg). Rage that escapes the reins is not courage. It is the horse bolting, and a bolting horse can be steered by whoever frightens it.

The practical answer​

  • Violence is a crime. It puts the parent in prison instead of in the room where the decision is made.
  • It hands the other side a reason to stop listening. On 24 August 1970, four men bombed Sterling Hall at the University of Wisconsin–Madison to protest military research; the blast killed a physics researcher (Wikipedia, Sterling Hall bombing).
  • It is unnecessary. Every parents' movement that changed events, from Another Mother for Peace to Israel's Four Mothers, used letters, lobbying, demonstrations, and votes. See Parents Who Organized Before.
  • Even nonviolent law-breaking costs dearly. Vietnam-era raids on draft boards sent people to prison (Draft Resistance and the Law), and in 1969 "legislators in seven states passed laws to punish student activists who had been arrested during protests" (historian Lauren Lassabe Shepherd, as posted by Owen Gregorian).

A voice from the right on method​

Novelist-philosopher Ayn Rand, writing during the Vietnam draft, argued: "A forced compliance is not a sanction... Unjust laws have to be fought ideologically; they cannot be fought or corrected by means of mere disobedience and futile martyrdom," quoting a 1967 editorial: "One does not stop the juggernaut by throwing oneself in front of it" (as quoted on X, 24 September 2026). Parents do not have to agree with her on anything else to take her point: change the law; do not break yourself against it.

Watch for provocation​

Posts on X in 2026 predicted a "false flag" attack to generate support for a ground invasion; one line printed on a trending page read: "Israel/US would hit America with a false flag attack if deemed necessary to crump up support for a longer war or ground invasion" (X trending, 6 April 2026). Whatever one thinks of that claim, it names the danger: an act of violence, by anyone, is the event most likely to turn public opinion toward a ground war and a draft. A parents' movement that stays calm and lawful gives no one that excuse.

Sources​

Status: Ayn Rand: Deceased (1982). Plato: Deceased (c. 348 BC).

Last Updated: 2026-09-26

Last updated on