Skip to main content

< Back to Consciousness & Deep State | Book List

Book: Penetration

The Question of Extraterrestrial and Human Telepathy

FieldDetails
TitlePenetration: The Question of Extraterrestrial and Human Telepathy
AuthorIngo Swann (1933--2013)
Year1998 (self-published); Special Edition reissued 2019 by Swann-Ryder Productions
PublisherIngo Swann Books (ISBN 0-9667674-0-3)
Pages~220
CategoryRemote Viewing / Government Programs / Consciousness / Extraterrestrial Contact
Charter Fit Score10/10
Evidence StrengthSTRONG EVIDENCE

Why This Book Matters to the Charter​

Ingo Swann is not a casual commentator on consciousness -- he is the person who co-created the discipline of remote viewing with Dr. Harold Puthoff at Stanford Research Institute (SRI) in 1972, coined the term "remote viewing," and served as the primary subject and protocol designer for the CIA's Project SCANATE and the broader Stargate program that ran for over two decades. When Swann writes about government involvement in consciousness research, he is writing from direct, firsthand experience inside classified programs. No other author in this project has a comparable level of insider access to the intersection of intelligence agencies and consciousness research.

Penetration reveals that beyond the known CIA remote viewing programs, there existed an even deeper layer of "deep black" operations -- an unnamed agency with no paper trail, no written secrecy agreements, and a specific charter focused on extraterrestrial intelligence, telepathy, and what was really on the Moon. Swann claims he was recruited by this shadow agency, taken to an underground facility near Washington, D.C., asked to remote view the far side of the Moon (where he reported finding structures, machinery, lights, and humanoid beings), and later transported to a remote site near the Arctic Circle where he allegedly witnessed a massive UFO extracting water from a lake. The book directly documents what the deep state allegedly knows about non-human intelligence and why that knowledge is suppressed.

The book also advances a thesis central to this project's charter: that human telepathy is a real but undeveloped capacity, that extraterrestrial beings possess fully developed telepathic abilities, and that the government's interest in consciousness is driven not by curiosity but by the national security implications of telepathic contact with non-human intelligence. This connects the Gateway thesis, the Non-Local Psi thesis, and the Other Dimensions / UAP thesis into a single firsthand account from someone who was inside the machine.

Key Claims & Evidence​

  • A "deep black" agency exists beyond the CIA and DIA that specifically monitors extraterrestrial activity and telepathic phenomena, operating without any paper trail or formal secrecy agreements
  • The Moon is not a dead rock -- Swann claims he remote viewed structures on the far side of the Moon including towers, machinery, bridges, domes, lights of various colors, and "strange-looking buildings"
  • Humanoid beings are present on the Moon -- Swann reported observing naked humanoid figures engaged in what appeared to be mining or construction activity; when two of them appeared to detect his remote viewing presence and pointed at him, his handler "Mr. Axelrod" urgently told him to withdraw
  • ET beings have infiltrated Earth -- Swann describes an encounter in a Los Angeles supermarket in 1976 where he observed a woman he believed was an extraterrestrial in human disguise, who emanated a telepathic "buzz" or scanning signal that he could perceive
  • A massive UFO was witnessed near the Arctic Circle -- Swann claims he was transported to a remote Alaskan location where he witnessed a roughly 90-foot diamond or triangular shaped craft hovering over a lake, extracting water; when it detected their presence, it allegedly fired upon them
  • Human telepathy is deliberately undeveloped -- the book argues that human beings possess latent telepathic abilities that remain suppressed or undeveloped, while extraterrestrial beings have fully developed these capacities
  • Manned lunar missions ceased because of ET presence -- Swann presents the thesis that the real reason NASA stopped sending astronauts to the Moon was the discovery of extraterrestrial activity there
  • The government knows far more about extraterrestrials than it admits -- the overarching thesis is that multiple layers of the intelligence community are aware of non-human intelligence, study it in classified programs, and actively suppress public knowledge of it

Charter-Relevant Content​

Government Consciousness Programs​

Ingo Swann was present at the creation of government remote viewing. In 1972, he demonstrated psychokinetic effects on a shielded magnetometer at Stanford University's Varian Physics Building for Dr. Arthur Heberd and Dr. Harold Puthoff -- an experiment that reportedly caught the CIA's attention. This led directly to Project SCANATE (1973--1974), the first CIA-funded remote viewing program at SRI, where Swann and Pat Price served as the primary remote viewers under the Office of Technical Services and the Directorate of Science and Technology.

Swann developed the Controlled Remote Viewing (CRV) protocol -- the standardized methodology that the government used for over two decades. His 1973 remote viewing of Jupiter, conducted before any spacecraft had reached the planet, described features later confirmed by Pioneer 10, Pioneer 11, Voyager 1, and Voyager 2: a hydrogen mantle, water/ice crystals, radio-reflective crystal bands, tornado-like cyclones, magnetic auroras, and a planetary ring inside the atmosphere.

Penetration reveals that while Swann was working at SRI on the "known" classified programs, he was simultaneously recruited by an even more secret agency for work that went far beyond coordinate remote viewing of terrestrial targets.

"Deep Black" Operations​

The central narrative of Part One involves a figure Swann calls "Mr. Axelrod" (a pseudonym) who represented an agency that, in Axelrod's words, "exists without leaving a paper trail regarding our mission." Key details:

  • Recruitment: Swann was contacted and recruited outside the known SRI/CIA channels
  • No written agreements: The agency operated on verbal secrecy agreements only, with no documentation -- Swann notes this is why he was eventually able to write about it after the verbal agreement expired
  • Underground facility: Swann was picked up by two military-looking escorts, blindfolded with a black hood, and taken to an underground facility near Washington, D.C.
  • Compensation: He was paid $1,000 per day -- a substantial sum in the mid-1970s
  • Moon remote viewing sessions: At this facility, Axelrod directed Swann to remote view specific coordinates on the Moon, particularly the far side
  • Arctic expedition: Swann was later transported to a remote location near the Arctic Circle to observe UFO activity over an Alaskan lake
  • The UFO encounter: They witnessed a massive craft (approximately 90 feet, diamond or triangular) hovering over the lake and extracting water. When it detected their observation, it reportedly fired upon them

The implication is that the intelligence community operates a layered system: the "known" classified programs (SCANATE, Stargate) are themselves a cover layer, beneath which exist even deeper programs focused on non-human intelligence.

Extraterrestrial / NHI Connection​

Swann's Moon remote viewing sessions yielded extraordinary claims:

  • Structures: Towers, machinery, bridges (one arching out and never landing), domes of various sizes, round objects, small saucer-shaped objects with windows
  • Lights: Lights of different colors visible on the lunar surface
  • Atmosphere: Swann reported the Moon has an atmosphere -- a claim Axelrod did not dispute
  • Humanoid beings: Naked humanoid figures engaged in activity resembling mining or construction
  • Telepathic detection: Two of the beings appeared to detect Swann's remote viewing presence and pointed in his direction, prompting Axelrod to order an immediate withdrawal

The supermarket encounter in Los Angeles adds another dimension: Swann describes a woman with "excessive female physical endowments" who radiated a telepathic "buzz" he could perceive. Swann became convinced she was an extraterrestrial being in human disguise and that such infiltrations are more common than people realize.

Suppression of Information​

The book documents multiple layers of suppression:

  • Classification of consciousness research: The government classified remote viewing results that revealed non-human activity, burying them in compartmented programs
  • No paper trail by design: The deep black agency deliberately operated without documentation, making FOIA requests and congressional oversight impossible
  • Verbal-only secrecy: By avoiding written agreements, the agency ensured that even the existence of the program could be denied
  • Lunar exploration ceased: Swann argues that the cessation of manned Moon missions after Apollo 17 in 1972 was a direct result of discovering ET presence -- the public was told it was budget cuts
  • Telepathy research suppressed: Despite evidence that human telepathy is real and that ET beings possess advanced telepathic capabilities, this research was buried rather than pursued openly

Key Quotes​

"I found towers, machinery, lights of different colors, strange-looking 'buildings.' I found bridges whose function I could not figure out. One of them just arched out -- and never landed anywhere. There were a lot of domes of various sizes, round things, things like small saucers with windows." -- Ingo Swann, Penetration, describing his remote viewing of the Moon's far side

"We exist without leaving a paper trail regarding our mission." -- "Mr. Axelrod" (pseudonym), as quoted by Swann in Penetration, describing the deep black agency

"Swann is the father of remote viewing. Swann developed the protocol for and conducted the first-ever remote viewing experiment, and coined the term for it in 1971 while working with researchers at the American Society of Psychical Research in New York." -- Ingo Swann official biography, ingoswann.com

The Counterargument​

Several significant criticisms and counterarguments exist regarding Penetration:

  • Russell Targ's assessment: Targ, who worked directly with Swann at SRI and is one of the founders of the remote viewing program, stated: "My opinion is that if Penetration was nonfiction, Ingo would not have written it as he did." This is a significant criticism from someone who knew Swann well and believed in remote viewing -- Targ is not a general skeptic, but he questioned the factual basis of this specific book
  • No independent corroboration: The events described in Penetration -- the underground facility, Axelrod, the Arctic UFO encounter, the Moon structures -- have never been independently verified by any other source. No other participant has come forward
  • The "no paper trail" problem: The claim that the agency deliberately left no documentation is unfalsifiable -- there is no way to confirm or deny the agency's existence precisely because no records allegedly exist
  • General skepticism of remote viewing: The broader scientific community regards remote viewing as pseudoscience. Psychologists David Marks and Richard Kammann attempted to replicate Targ and Puthoff's SRI experiments in 35 studies, could not replicate the results, and found methodological flaws including inadvertent clues left in session notes
  • The AIR evaluation (1995): The American Institutes for Research, in their evaluation of Project Stargate, concluded that remote viewing had not produced actionable intelligence for any intelligence operation
  • Narrative style: The book reads more like a thriller or adventure story than a scientific report, which has led some readers and reviewers to question whether it should be classified as autobiography, memoir, or fictionalized account
  • The supermarket encounter: The claim of encountering a disguised extraterrestrial in a Los Angeles supermarket is regarded even by sympathetic readers as the weakest and most speculative portion of the book

Connection to Other Project Entries​

  • Gateway / Consciousness Simulator -- Swann's work at SRI was contemporaneous with and related to the CIA's investigation of the Gateway Process. Both programs explored whether consciousness could operate non-locally. The Gateway Analysis (declassified CIA document) and Swann's remote viewing protocols share the foundational premise that consciousness is not confined to the brain
  • Non-Local Psi / Information Field -- Swann's entire career is primary evidence for this thesis. His remote viewing of Jupiter (later confirmed by spacecraft), his magnetometer experiments at Stanford, and the 23-year Stargate program he helped create are central evidence cited by psi researchers
  • Joe McMoneagle -- McMoneagle was the other premier remote viewer in the Stargate program (Remote Viewer #001). While McMoneagle has been more cautious about ET claims, his work validates the same underlying phenomenon Swann describes
  • Robert Monroe -- Monroe's out-of-body exploration mapped non-physical dimensions (Focus Levels) that parallel Swann's descriptions of accessing non-local information. Monroe's Gateway Hemi-Sync technology was investigated by the same intelligence community that funded Swann's work
  • Tom Campbell -- Campbell's My Big TOE theory that reality is a consciousness-based simulator aligns with Swann's premise that consciousness can access information anywhere, including the Moon and other planets
  • Other Dimensions / UAP / Religious -- Swann's Arctic UFO encounter and Moon observations directly support the thesis that non-human intelligences operate from other dimensions or locations beyond normal human perception
  • Jacques Vallee -- Vallee's interdimensional hypothesis for UAP phenomena aligns with Swann's account of encountering non-human intelligence through consciousness rather than physical travel
  • Stephan Schwartz -- Schwartz worked with remote viewing in archaeological applications, part of the same SRI-originated research tradition that Swann founded
  • Courtney Brown -- Brown's Farsight Institute continues remote viewing work in the tradition Swann established, including remote viewing of extraterrestrial targets
  • Dean Radin -- Radin's meta-analyses of psi research provide statistical validation for the type of non-local consciousness Swann demonstrated
  • DMT and Consciousness Travel -- DMT experiencers report encounters with non-human entities in other dimensions, paralleling Swann's claims of encountering non-human beings through remote viewing -- different access methods, potentially the same phenomenon
  • Diana Pasulka -- Pasulka documents how government insiders have long known about non-human intelligence, consistent with Swann's account of deep black programs studying ET activity
  • Grant Cameron -- Cameron's research into government UFO secrecy and the "consciousness connection" to the UAP phenomenon aligns with Swann's claims about classified consciousness programs focused on ET contact
  • Whitley Strieber -- Strieber's contact experiences with non-human intelligence parallel Swann's claims of encountering ET beings, though through different means (abduction vs. remote viewing)

Other Coverage Worth Reading​

Sources​

This information was compiled by Claude AI research.