Skip to main content

< Back to Main List

Coleen Rowley

FBI Special Agent and whistleblower who exposed how FBI headquarters blocked the Minneapolis field office's investigation of Zacarias Moussaoui weeks before the September 11 attacks, revealing systemic intelligence failures that could have prevented the worst terrorist attack on American soil.

FieldDetails
Full NameColeen Mary Rowley
BornDecember 20, 1954, New Hampton, Iowa
RoleFBI Special Agent / Whistleblower / Attorney
PlatformSenate testimony, TIME Magazine, investigative journalism, anti-war activism
Notable Works13-page memo to FBI Director Robert Mueller (May 21, 2002); Senate Judiciary Committee testimony (June 6, 2002); open letter to Mueller opposing Iraq War (February 2003)
StatusACTIVE
Evidence RatingWELL-DOCUMENTED
Current AffiliationsVeteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS), Women Against Military Madness, Eisenhower Media Network

FBI Career (1981-2004)​

Coleen Rowley joined the FBI as a Special Agent in January 1981, after earning a B.A. with honors in French from Wartburg College (1977) and a J.D. from the University of Iowa College of Law (1980). Over her 24-year career, she served in the Omaha, Nebraska and Jackson, Mississippi field offices before spending six years (1984-1990) in the New York City field office investigating Italian organized crime and Sicilian heroin trafficking.

In 1990, she transferred to the FBI's Minneapolis field office, where she became Chief Division Counsel. In that role she taught constitutional law to FBI agents and police officers and oversaw the Freedom of Information, Asset Forfeiture, Victim-Witness, and community outreach programs. She held a Top Secret security clearance and had direct operational knowledge of how the FBI handled intelligence and counterterrorism cases.

The Moussaoui Case: How FBI Headquarters Blocked the Investigation​

The Tip (August 2001)​

In mid-August 2001 -- just three weeks before 9/11 -- instructors at the Pan Am International Flight Academy in Eagan, Minnesota contacted the FBI's Minneapolis field office with an alarming report: a French citizen of Moroccan descent named Zacarias Moussaoui had enrolled in Boeing 747 flight simulator training. He had paid approximately $8,000 in cash. He had no pilot's license and no apparent reason to learn to fly a jumbo jet. The instructors found his behavior suspicious and potentially threatening.

Minneapolis agents, including Rowley and Special Agent Harry Samit, arrested Moussaoui on August 16, 2001 on an immigration violation. They quickly identified him as a potential terrorist threat and sought authorization to search his laptop computer and personal belongings.

FBI Headquarters Stonewalls​

What followed was a series of decisions by FBI headquarters that Rowley would later describe as "almost inexplicable." The Minneapolis field office sought a warrant under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) to search Moussaoui's laptop and belongings. This required establishing that Moussaoui was an agent of a foreign power.

French intelligence (the Direction Generale de la Securite Exterieure, or DGSE) had provided information connecting Moussaoui to Chechen rebel groups with ties to al-Qaeda. Minneapolis agents believed this established the necessary probable cause for a FISA warrant.

However, officials at FBI headquarters -- specifically David Frasca, Chief of the Radical Fundamentalist Unit (RFU) of the Counterterrorism Division, and Supervisory Special Agent Michael Maltbie in that unit -- repeatedly rejected Minneapolis' requests. According to Rowley's memo:

  • HQ personnel edited and altered Minneapolis' FISA warrant request, removing key information that supported probable cause.
  • HQ personnel "brought up almost ridiculous questions in their apparent efforts to undermine the probable cause."
  • HQ officials "continued to, almost inexplicably, throw up roadblocks and undermine Minneapolis' by-now desperate efforts to obtain a FISA search warrant."
  • FBI headquarters never disclosed to Minneapolis agents that the Phoenix Division had, only approximately three weeks earlier, sent the so-called "Phoenix Memo" warning that al-Qaeda operatives were enrolling in U.S. flight schools for potential terrorist purposes.

Minneapolis agents were so frustrated that one agent reportedly told headquarters that he was "trying to keep someone from taking a plane and releasing chemical weapons into the cockpit" -- a warning that went unheeded. The FISA warrant was never obtained before September 11.

What the Laptop Contained​

After 9/11, when the laptop was finally searched under an ordinary criminal warrant, investigators found information connecting Moussaoui to the 9/11 hijackers and to the broader al-Qaeda plot. Moussaoui was later convicted as the "20th hijacker" and sentenced to life in prison.

The 13-Page Memo (May 21, 2002)​

In May 2002, after watching FBI Director Robert Mueller publicly claim that the FBI could not have prevented the 9/11 attacks, Rowley spent several hours drafting a 13-page memo addressed directly to Mueller. The memo was a detailed, point-by-point account of how FBI headquarters had obstructed the Minneapolis investigation and how the Bureau's post-9/11 claims were misleading.

Rowley hand-delivered one copy to Mueller's office and provided two additional copies to members of the Senate Intelligence Committee. The memo was subsequently leaked to the press, becoming front-page news nationwide.

The Memo's Core Claims​

  1. Active obstruction, not mere negligence: FBI headquarters did not simply fail to act -- officials actively removed information from the FISA request and threw up roadblocks to prevent the warrant from being obtained.

  2. Pattern of headquarters arrogance: The memo documented a culture at FBI headquarters in which field agents' operational judgment was routinely overruled by officials far from the investigation.

  3. Failure to connect the dots: FBI HQ failed to share the Phoenix Memo with Minneapolis, which would have significantly strengthened the case for a FISA warrant by establishing the broader pattern of al-Qaeda operatives in flight schools.

  4. Post-9/11 cover-up: Rowley accused FBI leadership of attempting to rewrite history after 9/11, claiming "the risk of embarrassment" drove officials to obstruct an honest accounting of what went wrong.

  5. No accountability: The headquarters officials who blocked the warrant request faced no disciplinary action; some were promoted.

Key Quotes​

"It is obvious, from my firsthand knowledge of the events and the detailed documentation that exists, that the agents in Minneapolis who were closest to the action and in the best position to gauge the situation locally, did fully appreciate the terrorist risk/danger posed by Moussaoui and his possible co-conspirators even prior to September 11th." -- Coleen Rowley, Memo to FBI Director Robert Mueller, May 21, 2002

"HQ personnel brought up almost ridiculous questions in their apparent efforts to undermine the probable cause." -- Coleen Rowley, Memo to FBI Director Robert Mueller, May 21, 2002

"Key FBI HQ personnel... continued to, almost inexplicably, throw up roadblocks and undermine Minneapolis' by-now desperate efforts to obtain a FISA search warrant." -- Coleen Rowley, Memo to FBI Director Robert Mueller, May 21, 2002

"I feel that certain facts... have, up to now, been omitted, downplayed, glossed over and/or mis-characterized in an effort to avoid or minimize personal and/or institutional embarrassment on the part of the FBI and/or perhaps even for improper political reasons." -- Coleen Rowley, Memo to FBI Director Robert Mueller, May 21, 2002

Senate Judiciary Committee Testimony (June 6, 2002)​

On June 6, 2002, Rowley testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee about the FBI's pre-9/11 failures. Her testimony elaborated on the points in her memo and addressed systemic problems within the FBI bureaucracy that frustrated agents' attempts at innovative investigation and mired them in paperwork. She described a culture of risk aversion at headquarters where officials were more concerned with avoiding blame than with preventing terrorism.

Her testimony, combined with the memo, was instrumental in prompting FBI Director Mueller to announce a major reorganization of the FBI, shifting resources toward counterterrorism and intelligence-gathering.

Rowley also provided information to the 9/11 Commission regarding the FBI's internal failures.

TIME Person of the Year (2002)​

In December 2002, TIME Magazine named Rowley as one of three co-Persons of the Year under the banner "The Whistleblowers." She shared the honor with Sherron Watkins (who exposed fraud at Enron) and Cynthia Cooper (who uncovered accounting fraud at WorldCom). The recognition highlighted the critical role whistleblowers play in holding powerful institutions accountable.

Current Situation​

Rowley retired from the FBI at the end of 2004 after 24 years of service. Unlike some whistleblowers who faced prosecution or imprisonment, Rowley's high-profile recognition by TIME Magazine and her Senate testimony provided a degree of public protection. However, she has described the internal pressures and career consequences that come with challenging the Bureau from within.

Post-FBI Political Career​

In February 2003, while still at the FBI, Rowley wrote a second open letter to Mueller warning that the invasion of Iraq would be counterproductive and would generate a "flood of terrorism" directed at the United States. This letter marked her transition from internal critic to public anti-war voice.

In 2005, she announced her candidacy for the U.S. House of Representatives in Minnesota's 2nd Congressional District as a Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party (DFL) candidate. Running on a platform emphasizing FBI reform, civil liberties, and opposition to the Iraq War, she lost the November 2006 general election to Republican incumbent John Kline, receiving 44.1% of the vote.

Ongoing Activism​

Rowley remains active as a writer, speaker, and advocate for government accountability and anti-war causes. She is a member of:

  • Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS) -- a group of former intelligence professionals who challenge misleading intelligence claims
  • Women Against Military Madness
  • Eisenhower Media Network -- an organization of national security professionals promoting informed public discourse

She has written for outlets including the Huffington Post, CounterPunch, and the Minneapolis Star Tribune, and has continued to speak publicly about FBI failures, the post-9/11 surveillance state, and the consequences of the Iraq War.

Why This Person Matters​

Coleen Rowley's case is one of the most thoroughly documented examples of pre-9/11 intelligence failure. Her memo and testimony provided direct, firsthand evidence that:

  1. Field agents identified the threat: The FBI's Minneapolis office correctly assessed Moussaoui as a terrorist threat weeks before 9/11.
  2. Headquarters actively obstructed: This was not a passive failure to "connect the dots" but an active blocking of investigation by named officials.
  3. No accountability followed: Officials who blocked the investigation were not punished; some were promoted.
  4. The official narrative was misleading: FBI leadership's post-9/11 claims that the attacks could not have been prevented were contradicted by Rowley's firsthand account.
  5. Systemic problems persisted: The bureaucratic culture that produced the failure was deeply embedded in the FBI's institutional structure.

Her case raises a fundamental question about the pre-9/11 intelligence failures: were they the product of incompetence and bureaucratic inertia, or was something more deliberate at work? The fact that headquarters officials actively removed information from warrant requests, refused to share the Phoenix Memo with Minneapolis, and faced no consequences afterward has fueled broader questions about whether elements within the intelligence community allowed the attacks to happen.

The Counterargument​

  • Institutional defenders have argued that the FBI's pre-9/11 failures reflected systemic problems -- the "wall" between intelligence and criminal investigations, inadequate information-sharing protocols, and risk-averse legal interpretations -- rather than deliberate obstruction.
  • The 9/11 Commission attributed the failures to institutional culture and legal barriers rather than intentional blocking, though it acknowledged the specific failures Rowley documented.
  • FBI leadership accepted that mistakes were made but characterized them as the product of an outdated organizational structure, which Mueller's subsequent reforms sought to address.
  • Some critics have noted that Rowley's memo was written after the fact and that pre-9/11 hindsight makes the significance of the Moussaoui case clearer than it may have appeared at the time, though Minneapolis agents' contemporaneous warnings undercut this argument.
  • Sibel Edmonds -- Another FBI whistleblower who exposed intelligence failures and alleged deliberate suppression of pre-9/11 intelligence, corroborating the pattern Rowley identified
  • Philip Zelikow -- Executive Director of the 9/11 Commission, which investigated the FBI failures Rowley documented but has been criticized for limiting the scope of its inquiry
  • Bob Graham -- Former Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman who investigated the intelligence failures and pushed for declassification of the 28 pages on Saudi involvement, complementing Rowley's account of institutional obstruction

Other Coverage Worth Reading​

  • Richard Gage: Architect who organized 3,500+ professionals challenging the official account of how three World Trade Center towers collapsed.
  • Niels Harrit: University of Copenhagen chemist who published peer-reviewed findings of unexploded nanothermite in WTC dust samples.
  • Susan Lindauer: CIA asset arrested under the Patriot Act after warning of the 9/11 attacks months in advance through intelligence channels.
  • Christopher Bollyn: Investigative journalist who traced connections between the 9/11 attacks and foreign intelligence operations in the United States.

Sources​

This information was compiled by Claude AI research.