Skip to main content

< Back to Main List

The Dancing Israelis

Five Israeli nationals arrested on September 11, 2001 after being observed filming and apparently celebrating the World Trade Center attacks from a position that required advance knowledge of the event — later identified by multiple sources as connected to Israeli intelligence.

FieldDetails
TypeIntelligence Operation / Foreknowledge Evidence
First Articulated ByEyewitnesses on 9/11; reported by ABC News (June 2002), The Forward (March 2002), and investigative journalists
Active PeriodSeptember 11, 2001 -- present (ongoing research)
Key ClaimFive Israeli men were positioned to film the WTC attacks before or as they began, were observed celebrating the destruction, and later stated on Israeli television that their purpose was "to document the event" — a statement that implies foreknowledge
Evidence RatingSTRONG EVIDENCE

Overview​

On the morning of September 11, 2001, a woman in an apartment building in Union City, New Jersey observed five men on the roof of a white van in the parking lot of her building, filming the World Trade Center and appearing to celebrate as the towers burned. She called the police, who issued a BOLO (Be On the Lookout) alert. The five men — Sivan Kurzberg, Paul Kurzberg, Yaron Shmuel, Oded Ellner, and Omer Marmari — were stopped and arrested later that day by East Rutherford, New Jersey police near Giants Stadium.

All five men were Israeli nationals employed by Urban Moving Systems, a moving company based in Weehawken, New Jersey, owned by Dominik Suter. The FBI investigation determined that the men were in the Doric apartment complex parking lot between approximately 8:50 AM and 9:03 AM — meaning they were positioned and filming after the first tower was struck (8:46 AM) but potentially before the second strike (9:03 AM).

The men were held for 71 days, during which they were interrogated by the FBI and reportedly failed polygraph tests. They were eventually deported to Israel in November 2001 for immigration violations. Upon returning to Israel, three of the men appeared on a television talk show where Oded Ellner stated: "Our purpose was to document the event." This statement — that their purpose was to document an event no one could have known about in advance — remains the most explosive aspect of the case.

Evidence & Documentation​

The Arrest​

The five men were observed by multiple witnesses at the Doric apartment complex parking lot in Union City, NJ, positioned on the roof of a white Urban Moving Systems van. Witnesses described them as filming the burning towers, with some witnesses reporting that the men appeared to be celebrating — high-fiving, hugging, and flicking cigarette lighters. One witness, Maria, called the police after observing what she described as celebratory behavior.

The BOLO was issued, and the van was stopped on Route 3 in East Rutherford at approximately 3:56 PM. At the time of the stop, Sivan Kurzberg, the driver, reportedly told the officers: "We are Israeli. We are not your problem. Your problems are our problems. The Palestinians are the problem."

FBI Investigation​

The FBI investigated the men under the code name "High Fivers." According to FBI documents partially released through FOIA:

  • The men had $4,700 in cash, box cutters, and multiple foreign passports
  • Maps were found with certain locations highlighted
  • Bomb-sniffing dogs reacted positively to the van
  • FBI radar records confirmed the men were at the Doric parking lot between 8:50 AM and 9:03 AM
  • At least two of the men (Paul Kurzberg and Sivan Kurzberg) reportedly failed polygraph tests
  • One of the men had photographs showing him holding a lit cigarette lighter in the foreground with the smoking WTC towers in the background

The FBI initially considered the men as suspected intelligence operatives. However, according to ABC News, the FBI "concluded that the five were conducting a Mossad surveillance mission and the potential suspect list was narrowed from approximately 30 to about five people."

The Five Men​

NameRoleDetails
Sivan KurzbergDriverMade the statement about Palestinians to arresting officers
Paul KurzbergReportedly refused to take a polygraph test for 10 weeks; eventually failed it
Yaron ShmuelPhotographed with cigarette lighter and burning towers
Oded EllnerMade the "our purpose was to document the event" statement on Israeli TV
Omer Marmari

"Our Purpose Was to Document the Event"​

Upon their return to Israel, three of the men — Ellner, Shmuel, and Marmari — appeared on the Israeli talk show Matzav Ha'uma (State of the Nation) in November 2001. Oded Ellner stated: "Our purpose was to document the event."

This statement is the single most significant piece of evidence in the case. If their purpose was to "document the event," they would have needed to know the event was going to happen. One cannot set up to document something that has not yet occurred unless one has advance knowledge.

Urban Moving Systems and Dominik Suter​

The five men worked for Urban Moving Systems, a moving company in Weehawken, NJ owned by Israeli national Dominik Suter. After the arrests, the FBI raided Urban Moving Systems' offices. According to ABC News, the FBI determined that the company was likely a Mossad front operation.

Dominik Suter fled the United States to Israel on September 14, 2001 — three days after the attacks and before the FBI could interview him further. He was placed on the FBI's suspect list. The business was shut down and the building vacated. Suter's name later appeared on the FBI's list of individuals sought for questioning.

The Broader Context: Israeli Intelligence Activity​

The Dancing Israelis case does not exist in isolation. It is part of a documented pattern of Israeli intelligence activity surrounding 9/11:

  • The DEA report documented approximately 140 Israeli intelligence operatives detained in the US in 2001, many posing as art students (see Mossad)
  • Israeli-owned Odigo messaging company employees received warnings 2 hours before the attacks (see Odigo Warning)
  • Fox News aired a 4-part investigation by Carl Cameron on the Israeli spy ring, then pulled it from their website (see Mossad)
  • The broader Israeli Foreknowledge / Mossad profile documents the full scope of these activities

The Forward Report​

The Jewish newspaper The Forward reported on March 15, 2002 that the FBI had concluded that at least two of the five Israelis were Mossad operatives. The article stated: "According to one former high-ranking American intelligence official, who asked not to be named, the FBI came to the conclusion at the end of its investigation that the five Israelis arrested in New Jersey last September were conducting a Mossad surveillance mission."

Key Figures​

  • Sivan Kurzberg, Paul Kurzberg, Yaron Shmuel, Oded Ellner, Omer Marmari — The five detained Israelis
  • Dominik Suter — Owner of Urban Moving Systems; fled to Israel on September 14, 2001
  • Christopher Bollyn — Journalist who extensively investigated the Dancing Israelis and Israeli intelligence connections to 9/11
  • Sibel Edmonds — FBI whistleblower whose broader testimony about foreign intelligence penetration provides context

Criticisms & Counter-Arguments​

  • ABC News reported that the FBI "concluded that the five Israelis had no foreknowledge of the attacks." However, this statement appears to conflict with the FBI's own classification of the investigation and the Forward's reporting that two were identified as Mossad operatives.
  • Israeli government — Israel has denied that the men were intelligence operatives, stating they were simply young Israelis working abroad.
  • Filming timing — FBI radar records place the men at the parking lot starting at 8:50 AM, which is after the first plane struck at 8:46 AM. The official position is that they, like many people, began filming after seeing the first impact — not before it.
  • "Document the event" translation — Some have argued the Hebrew statement was mistranslated or taken out of context, and that Ellner meant they documented the event as it was unfolding (after seeing the first strike), not that they had positioned themselves in advance.
  • Celebration claims — Some witnesses described the men as simply filming, not celebrating. The "dancing" description may be exaggerated.
  • Anti-Semitism concerns — Organizations including the Anti-Defamation League have characterized the Dancing Israelis story as anti-Semitic conspiracy theory. This project documents the factual record as reported by the FBI, ABC News, The Forward, and other mainstream sources.

See Also​

  • Israeli Foreknowledge / Mossad — The comprehensive profile of Israeli intelligence activities surrounding 9/11
  • Urban Moving Systems — The company that employed the five men, determined to be a likely Mossad front
  • Mossad — Israeli intelligence service and its alleged role in 9/11
  • Odigo Warning — Israeli messaging company employees warned 2 hours before the attacks
  • Christopher Bollyn — Journalist who investigated the Israeli connection and was arrested and exiled

Other Coverage Worth Reading​

  • Israeli Foreknowledge / Mossad: DEA documented 140+ Israeli operatives in the US, an Israeli company received warnings, and Fox News aired the story then deleted it.
  • Odigo Warning: Employees at an Israeli-owned messaging company received specific warnings two hours before the WTC attacks.
  • William Rodriguez: The last man rescued from the North Tower reported massive sub-basement explosions before the plane impact — omitted from the Commission report.
  • Coleen Rowley: FBI agent proved headquarters deliberately blocked the Moussaoui investigation — TIME Person of the Year for exposing the cover-up.

Sources​

This information was compiled by Claude AI research.